stories, lessons, and a lot of nonsense

Two weeks ago, I alluded to the fact that I would be writing about the Bible every Friday for a while.  Then work got in the way.  I think I sat in front of my computer for less than an hour combined between Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday.  By the end of Sunday, it wasn’t Friday anymore.  The week usually works like that, where the end of Sunday is after Friday.  So I’m exactly one week late with my second weekly post.  I said we’d be talking about predestination, so let’s do that.

There are basically three schools of thought on predestination: God has chosen Heaven or Hell for everyone; God has chosen Heaven or Hell for no one, and everyone has free will (this is how I was taught growing up); and God predestines some, and He gives free will to others (what I have come to believe).

When you are reading the Bible, and you are trying to make sense of some of the trickier passages, it’s important to consider the rest of Scripture before coming to a final conclusion.  Again, we are told to study, so we can come to the right conclusions.  It really is that important.  Based on my studying, I can no longer believe in absolute free will, and I haven’t switched to unconditional predestination.  And to be honest, most people I know that say they believe in absolute free will don’t.  They just haven’t connected two dots in their brain that are kept in separate compartments.

First, let’s look at the passage of Scripture that my belief comes from: Romans 9:18-23.  God can choose who He will show mercy to and harden who He will harden.  He will make some vessels for honor and some for dishonor.  Some are vessels for His wrath, and some are vessels for His mercy.  Some people are created with an afterlife reservations already made, both for Heaven and for Hell.

Right now, you might not be tracking with me, and that’s fine.  You might not agree with me by the end of this post, and that’s fine, too.  But let me ask you some questions.  Do you believe Judas Iscariot went to Heaven?  I don’t.  I wrote a compelling paper on how we know he got saved when I was in Bible college, but that was just to annoy my teacher and classmates.  I don’t believe it.  First of all, Jesus refers to him in John 17:12 as the son of perdition.  That word means “destruction (physical, spiritual, and eternal), ruined, lost, or damnable.”  Jesus also said in Matthew 26:24 that it would have been better if he had never been born.  If he had gone to Heaven, that couldn’t really be said.  None of this really matters if you believe Judas chose to be the way that he was.  But he was a fulfillment of prophecy.  It was prophesied that a person that shared bread with the Messiah would be the one to betray Him.

Here’s my next question: are the 144,000 witnesses in Revelation going to Heaven?  Have they already been chosen for their tasks? I believe the answer to both questions is yes.  They’ve already been sealed with a mark of protection so that they can fulfill their duty.  When they are mentioned in Revelation 14, it says that they were redeemed.  You might say they are…wait for it…predestined for Heaven, as they are already chosen for their purpose.

I’ve always believed both that Judas was chosen to be the son of perdition, therefore he went to hell, and that the 144,000 witnesses have already been sealed as God’s witnesses.  That means they go to Heaven.  You can argue that God chose them because they knew, but then others could argue that God knew, so He chose.  Circumlocution isn’t welcomed here.  But how could I believe that God offers free will to everyone if I also believe that there are some who have been chosen?  I can’t.  I had to come to the conclusion that God does offer free will, as He promised, but He reserves the right to make specific decisions.  Is it fair?  Not really, but that’s not my call, and it isn’t my business.  I’m just the clay.

Is this topic worth all the debate it’s gotten over the years?  I don’t think it is, so long as you are obeying Jesus’ teaching.  Whatever you believe, it’s important that you follow Jesus’ famous last words before ascending into Heaven: go and make disciples.  It’s your job to tell others, whether you believe everyone has divine reservations or not.  One thing my pastor growing up always said was that if total predestination were true, it’s okay, because the more you go out and share the gospel, the more predestined people you find.


Comments on: "predestination: it’s your density" (14)

  1. I see your point here. I’ve gone round and round with folks about predestination and free will. Of course God can choose whom he chooses, but here’s my question. Do you believe that you can lose your salvation? Or do you think that if someone rejects God he was never really saved in the first place? Also, do you believe God knows and controls every single minute detail of everyone’s life? If I have an opportunity to steal something but decide not to, did God will me not to steal it? Or was it my decision alone? I think there’s a difference between God knowing what we will do and God determining what we will do. Big difference.

    • I don’t believe someone can lose their salvation. Unless the person sinning is “greater than the Father,” he can’t do it, and no one is greater than God.

      And I don’t believe He controls every detail. I believe He does assert Himself sometimes with His providential will, but I don’t think He does that all the time. I’m not even sure that He inserts Himself in everyone’s life that way, either. I also think that for the most part, He offers free will salvation, but I also believe there are people in history (past and future) who have been predestined for one place or the other.

  2. Hi … found you via a tweet. So was that predestined? (sorry, couldn’t help it)

    According to the Bible, God is called a creator and a father … and we are made in his image. And I believe everyone has free will.

    So in light of your beliefs that not all people have free will … here’s some thoughts to ponder: You are a creator (writing) and you are a father … would you ever write something that you knew was doomed for destruction? And would you ever father another child if you knew that he/she would suffer forever?

    • Hello and welcome. We know His foreknowledge is absolute, so we know that He knowingly created children that are doomed to destruction. Now, whether He chose some is the question.

      As for me, I would write things that I know are doomed. I wrote this post, and 90% of my friends are Baptist. I’m a glutton for punishment. I would not father another child knowing he would suffer, but God did. And I wouldn’t father a child and choose for him to suffer. Would God? I think He did in some instances.

      Thanks for visiting and commenting.

      • Ok, so help me understand … with your belief do you feel like you had a choice to get saved (or not) and therefore go to Heaven (or not) or was that decided for you?

      • I believe I had a choice. I’m not saying I believe in total predestination. I believe God does choose some for a purpose, good or bad, but for the most part, deals in free will salvation.

  3. Q – What did the Calvinist say when he fell down the stairs?

    A – Ughh! Sure glad I got that over with.

    Okay, now to be serious, I don’t believe in predestination. As for Judas and prophecy, I believe that God KNEW of ahead of time but in no way CAUSED Judas’s betrayal. I guess I’m saying God can’t be surprised.

    • Ha! That’s a lot funnier than one might expect.

      Thanks for your comment, especially the funny part! I think God chose him and put him into a position to pull off what he did. That’s my opinion.

  4. Me again. Okay, if you can’t lose your salvation, then what about Judas? Was he baptized and it didn’t take?

  5. Nice can ‘o worms.

    Would love to see a definition from everybody on the sovereignty of God. I’m betting it means different things to different people but I am waaay curious.

    Love the conversation.

  6. I’m wondering if our background and others is more of a mish-mash. Here is my thoughts:

    We were taught that salvation is entirely our own decision. We choose when we pray a certain prayer. No one forces us, the choice is absolutely in our control. Election was downplayed and actually trivialized and taught on only as something we didn’t really comprehend so lets just hurry through the lesson.

    On the other hand, we were also taught that you could NOT choose to be unsaved. “Once saved always saved” was the saying. Which is ironic because the foundation of that is election.

    And if you asked anyone if God was in control of everything, the answer was a decidedly YES. And to make it more fun, if you ever listen to anyone pray, they absolutely were asking God to intervene in situations, change people and in effect, “cause” people to see things, understand things, etc.

    So, I wonder, why were we taught we have control in salvation matters but God has more control in everything else? Hehe….

    The mish-mash is fun.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: